Running a National Nature Reserve like Forvie is basically a delicate balancing act. On the one side we are tasked with protecting the Reserve’s wildlife and landscape, and on the other we must provide a service for its visitors. In other words, places like Forvie must be run for the benefit of both wildlife and people. This appears straightforward enough when it’s written down, but the reality on the ground is really quite different.

The problematic bottom line is that we (humanity) are the reason that wildlife is in trouble in the first place. We tend to have a deleterious effect on nature wherever we go. This can be as a result of our direct interactions with nature, such as killing wild creatures for food or profit (think the great whales, or indeed most of the world’s megafauna) and our use of land (e.g. clearing natural habitats for our crops, livestock and developments). And it can also occur through indirect effects, such as climate change or pollution of land and water. Put simply, you and I are generally bad news for nature (well, not just you and I personally, but I digress).

Humans on the whole aren’t daft, and we have recognised this problem for a very long time. Nature reserves – ostensibly places of refuge for what’s left of our beleaguered wildlife – are one of the ways we have tried to mitigate for all the damage we’ve caused in the wider natural world. Here in the UK we have more nature reserves (albeit mainly small ones) than many other countries in the world; it’s perhaps not a coincidence that we are also one of the most nature-depleted countries on the entire globe. Maybe all those nature reserves are proof of a guilty conscience!

For all the damage that we’ve already done, and continue to do, we still paradoxically think of ourselves as a ‘nation of animal lovers’. This is reflected in the number of us who keep pets. As we’ve mentioned in the past, other writers have suggested that this is a proxy for our lost connection with nature. But the monstrous irony is that our pets can also have a destructive effect on the natural world – even in supposedly ‘protected’ places like nature reserves.
Last year Forvie received about 75,000 human visitors (and that’s just on ‘our’ side of the River Ythan; this doesn’t include the thousands of visitors to Newburgh beach). A great many of those visitors brought their dogs with them. And why wouldn’t you? The Reserve offers great walks through an extensive open landscape, as well as having one of the best beaches on the entire planet. And once you’re on the Reserve, there’s no road traffic to worry about, nor any farm livestock to consider. So an ideal place to let the dog have a run around, right?

Whoa, hold your huskies though! Just like our opening paragraph, this isn’t quite as straightforward as it appears. Far from being a barren wasteland, Forvie is home to a wide range of sensitive and threatened wildlife, of national and even international importance – which is what sets it aside from (for example) a country park, or a city greenspace. The Reserve is supposed to offer a sanctuary for this wildlife, away from the anthropogenic pressures on the wider countryside. But this only works if the people who visit Forvie are willing to show a degree of restraint and consideration – particularly when it comes to exercising their pets.
In basic terms, a dog is a predator. A very tame and cute and cuddly one in our eyes at least, but a predator it remains. Or at least that’s how other creatures view it. Wild birds and mammals don’t make the distinction between a Labrador and a Wolf; to them it’s just a predator, and they react accordingly – flee for your life. And at this time of year, this burns up crucial energy that wild creatures can ill afford to spare. The cumulative effects of regular disturbance – which sadly happens at Forvie on a daily basis – can be fatal.

For birds, seals and deer, disturbance by dogs during the breeding season can cause the abandonment and death of their young. That’s why we operate the dogs-on-leads policy from April through August each year. Adherence to this request is variable at the best of times, but people on the whole are quite understanding. Sadly though, this has led to a situation whereby folk think that as soon as August is over, it’s a free-for-all. Fact is, Forvie doesn’t stop being a nature reserve overnight, and sensitivities remain throughout the year: feeding and roosting birds, deer calves, seals (and other visitors, for that matter). The Reserve needs to be treated with respect right through the year.

What’s more, direct damage to the wildlife isn’t the only issue. We’re perpetually tearing out what’s left of our hair due to the profusion of pet-related litter on the Reserve. Chewed-up tennis balls, the exploded remains of rubber toys, little plastic bags full of poo, and then there’s the un-bagged stuff that we’re constantly treading in. The latest craze seems to be owners allowing their pets to dig cavernous, ankle-breaking holes in the footpaths, without ever thinking to stop them doing so, or to fill in the holes. Excuse me while I stand up from the keyboard for a moment and scream into space. Come on people, surely we’re better than this?!

By common consensus among Reserve staff, confronting dog owners about the behaviour of their pets on the Reserve is one of the surest ways of earning us a faceful of abuse. It’s an interesting piece of psychology: seemingly to question the behaviour of someone’s dog is tantamount to calling them out as a bad parent. Please be assured that this is never our intention; we only ever aim to safeguard the wildlife that we love, and are obliged to do so by our employment and the law. We’re not killjoys for the sake of it, we’re simply trying to protect the Reserve and its inhabitants.

Opposition and criticism isn’t a one-way street though. As I said earlier on, it’s a balancing act, and the ‘dogs versus wildlife’ dilemma can result in slings and arrows from both sides. On the one hand, dog owners tend to get irritable about us placing restrictions on their recreational activity, while on the other hand, passionate naturalists often complain that we’re not doing enough to prevent disturbance and damage to wildlife on the Reserve (which is supposed to be a protected site for wildlife, right?). Who’d be a nature reserve warden?!

The Scottish Outdoor Access Code is built upon a basis of ‘rights with responsibilities’. But it’s the second of these that’s the dealbreaker. Everyone knows they have a right of open access in the Scottish countryside – including in places like nature reserves – but the bit that gets forgotten is that this only applies if that access is taken responsibly. And in Forvie’s case, this means taking care to ensure your visit doesn’t harm any of the things that make it such a special place.

A key point to make before I sign off is that we’re immensely grateful to those visitors (and their dogs of course) who do treat the Reserve and its wildlife with the respect it deserves, not least because you’re setting the example for others to follow. Thank you – on behalf of both the wildlife, and our own sanity.
Right, that’s me done for the week – away for a lie down in a darkened room now…






































































































































